UCA News



Updated: October 31, 2002 05:00 PM GMT
Support Asia's largest network of Catholic journalists and editors
Support Asia's largest network of Catholic journalists and editors
Share this article :

Catholic bishops in India´s Hindi speaking region say the reluctance of some Vatican officials to incorporate local cultural ethos in liturgical texts could hamper inculturation.

Liturgical books in Hindi "cannot and should not mean dry literal translations of Latin versions," Archbishop Benedict John Osta of Patna said at a recent meeting that involved 29 bishops from India´s northern region.

During their Oct. 20-21 meeting, the bishops discussed obstacles they face in having the Vatican approve Hindi translations of liturgical texts, including the Roman Missal, which contains Mass texts, and the Indian Anaphora (Eucharistic Prayer).

The Indian Anaphora was submitted to the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments in 1992. The Hindi translation of the Roman Missal was sent in 2000. The next year, however, the congregation issued "Liturgiam Authenticam" ("The Authentic Liturgy"), an instruction on liturgical translations. The document insists on almost-literal translations and close adherence to the style and structure of the original Latin.

Jesuit Archbishop Osta told fellow bishops that liturgy in Hindi was meant to generate greater participation of the faithful, but that would be impossible unless the translation "is in tune with the broader cultural canvas and creativity of the faithful." Several other bishops at the triennial gathering in Patna, the capital of Bihar state, some 1,015 kilometers east of Delhi, agreed that the reluctance of Vatican officials to reflect local culture in the liturgy would impede the inculturation process.

Belgian Jesuit Father Jos De Cuyper, 82, who convened a committee set up for the translations, told the meeting his group completed most of the work, including a translation of the Roman Missal "as per the directive of the Second Vatican Council," which encourages local cultural creativity in the liturgy. "But we abandoned publishing," he said, because the congregation "directed" translators to "skip local cultural creativity and meticulously revise the texts in accordance with their authentic Latin versions."

Archbishop Vincent Concessao of Delhi said the Vatican had also specified that the directive for inclusion of local cultural aspects in liturgy was not official. "This could greatly hamper the pace of inculturation that not only the Second Vatican Council emphasized, but all the popes have been repeatedly stressing," Archbishop Concessao said.

Archbishop Osta, a Sanskrit and Hindi scholar who pioneered the translation, said he had personally discussed the issue with leaders of the congregation, "but they did not respond very positively." Instead, he said, they "parried" by "saying they would deliberate over it in their plenary and then only would they be able to say something concrete."

The congregation, he added, insisted that the literal rendering of the Latin texts "is an attempt at safeguarding the ´unity of the Roman Rite.´" But "we simply cannot accept such logic, and we must make concerted and collective efforts to remove such restrictions," Archbishop Osta asserted.

Jesuit Bishop John Baptist Thakur of Muzaffarpur used the words "beyond comprehension" to describe the Vatican position. "Actually, it is not a question of translation," he observed. "It is a question of the mentality of the people in Rome" who want to control "from above" even the expression of devotion of culturally different people.

"We should not accept such dictates that could potentially hamper our mission of inculturation, which is indispensable for the Indian Church," Bishop Thakur continued. If cultural aspects are not given expression in faith life, he said, Christianity "would remain an alien faith, a foreign culture." That, he concluded, would only help Hindu groups to propagate their theory that Christians are foreigners and should be opposed.

Retired Jesuit Bishop J. Rodericks of Jamshedpur said the new statutes of the national conference of Latin-rite bishops authorize local bishops "to okay changes in the liturgy and then seek confirmation from Rome."

"Are Roman congregations authorized to restrict in a very substantial manner a decision taken by the Vatican council that allowed local cultural ethos to be incorporated in the liturgy?" Bishop Rodericks asked.

He said the region´s bishops could take up the matter with Pope John Paul II when they go for their next ad limina or five-yearly visit to Rome later this year. Accurate literal translation of the Latin versions of the liturgy is "not possible theologically and culturally," the retired bishop added.

Archbishop Telesphore Toppo of Ranchi said the Vatican congregation lately has "mellowed down a bit and is willing listen to our problems." The archbishop, who is president of the Conference of Catholic Bishops of India (Latin Rite), said the conference´s next biennial meeting in January 2003 will discuss the matter to prepare a paper for presentation to the pope.

"We must tell everyone firmly that the march of inculturation that followed Vatican Council II cannot be reversed," Archbishop Toppo said. "Any attempt to do so would only hurt the sentiments of our people. I am sure the Roman Curia would appreciate our views and needs." He also said the need of the region compels the Church to prepare a liturgy comprehensible to "even children and illiterates."

It was "impossible" to return liturgy to the "cultural background of the 7th-8th centuries in Rome when liturgical texts were composed in the language of Pope Leo the Great," he asserted. "We live in the present, and the local people yearn to live their faith within the indigenous cultural ambience."


Support UCA News...

As 2020 unfolds, we are asking readers like you to help us keep Union of Catholic Asian News (UCA News) free so it can be accessed from anywhere in the world at no cost.

That has been our policy for years and was made possible by donations from European Catholic funding agencies. However, like the Church in Europe, these agencies are in decline and the immediate and urgent claims on their funds for humanitarian emergencies in Africa and parts of Asia mean there is much less to distribute than there was even a decade ago.

Forty years ago, when UCA News was founded, Asia was a very different place - many poor and underdeveloped countries with large populations to feed, political instability and economies too often poised on the edge of collapse. Today, Asia is the economic engine room of the world and funding agencies quite rightly look to UCA News to do more to fund itself.

UCA News has a unique product developed from a view of the world and the Church through informed Catholic eyes. Our journalistic standards are as high as any in the quality press; our focus is particularly on a fast-growing part of the world - Asia - where, in some countries the Church is growing faster than pastoral resources can respond to - South Korea, Vietnam and India to name just three.

And UCA News has the advantage of having in its ranks local reporters that cover 22 countries and experienced native English-speaking editors to render stories that are informative, informed and perceptive.

We report from the ground where other news services simply can't or won't go. We report the stories of local people and their experiences in a way that Western news outlets simply don't have the resources to reach. And we report on the emerging life of new Churches in old lands where being a Catholic can at times be very dangerous.

With dwindling support from funding partners in Europe and the USA, we need to call on the support of those who benefit from our work.

Click here to find out the ways you can support UCA News. You can make a difference for as little as US$5...
UCAN Donate
Thank you. You are now signed up to our Daily Full Bulletin newsletter
Living Church - Contribute to help UCA News
Living Church - Contribute to help UCA News
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia