Sumatra churches forced to close

Indonesian authorities direct churches to merge or relocate following alleged pressure from Muslim majority
Sumatra churches forced to close

A Karo Batak Protestant church in Sumatra. Protestant churches in the region have been told by authorities to merge or relocate. (Photo from Wikimedia)

Protestants in a central region of Sumatra island in Muslim-majority Indonesia have been told by local authorities to relocate or merge their churches.

The directive was issued on Oct. 1 by Jambi city administration officials at an evening meeting with Methodist, Assemblies of God and Indonesian Christian Church representatives.

The gathering was held in the wake of personnel from an official organization called the Public Order Agency on Sept. 27 closing various churches based on regulations relating to building permission and other planning requirements.

"We haven't decided yet," Rev. Ojahan Tampubolon from the Indonesian Methodist Church, locally known as GMI, told Oct. 2 in relation to the relocation or merger options. "We need to discuss it first."

Rev. Ojahan Tampubolon said relocation would be difficult because the denomination's churches catering for some 500,000 worshipers are still in good condition and located near population centers.

Merging with other churches would be highly problematic given property ownership issues as well as each church having their own rules and organizational structures. "Let's say we do this, it will last only a month," he predicted in relation to the fate of any mergers.

After being established in 1999, GMI held Sunday services at homes and in a town shophouse.

In 2002, it built a church nearby following a protest from residents and the following year it constructed a two-story church.

GMI had applied for a building permit from the city administration but was not granted one.

Since 2006, churches across Indonesia have found themselves struggling to comply with a contentious joint ministerial decree regulating places of worship.

Issued by the religious affairs and home affairs ministries, it sets out onerous requirements, including that church officials provide a list of the names and signatures of 90 worshipers as well as proof of support from at least 60 non-church local residents.

The local village chief must also approve the construction of any new church.

Lipan Pasaribu, head of the Jambi-based division of the National and Political Unity Office, said the city administration hoped congregations would quickly choose between merging or relocating.

"Let them discuss," he told "Once they decide, the city administration will take further steps."

He said the church closures were aimed at preventing conflicts within communities rather than banning Christian services per se.

Sign up to receive UCAN Daily Full Bulletin
Thank you. You are now signed up to our Daily Full Bulletin newsletter
Pasaribu said a letter was circulated a day before the Sept. 27 closures warning that some 1,000 residents planned to protest against the churches. He complained that some churches are within 100 meters of each another.

However, the church closures have sparked strong criticism from Christian leaders.

Maximinus Purnomo, acting chairman of the Indonesian Catholic Society Forum in the Archdiocese of Jakarta, said the move threatened to erode interreligious tolerance.

"We call on the city administration to uphold the constitution and to immediately facilitate the legal process of the churches' permits based on the existing regulations," he said in a statement.

Irma Riana Simanjuntak, spokeswoman for the Communion of Churches in Indonesia, lamented that action against the churches involved followed pressure from members of the Muslim majority.

© Copyright 2018, All rights reserved
© Copyright 2018, Union of Catholic Asian News Limited. All rights reserved
Expect for any fair dealing permitted under the Hong Kong Copyright Ordinance.
No part of this publication may be reproduced by any means without prior permission.