UCA News

Priests, laity in India boycott Vatican appointee

The decision by officials of the Ernakulam-Angamaly Archdiocese may amount to 'defying the papal authority’
Lay people at the Ernakulam-Angamly archdiocese in the southern Indian state of Kerala take a pledge to not allow Arhcbihsop Andrews Thazhath, the apostolic administrator, to enter the Archbishop’s House accusing him of misleading the Vatican against their interest in a long-standing liturgical dispute. on Oct. 16

Lay people at the Ernakulam-Angamly archdiocese in the southern Indian state of Kerala take a pledge to not allow Arhcbihsop Andrews Thazhath, the apostolic administrator, to enter the Archbishop’s House accusing him of misleading the Vatican against their interest in a long-standing liturgical dispute. on Oct. 16. (Photo supplied)

Published: October 19, 2022 10:38 AM GMT
Updated: October 19, 2022 11:57 AM GMT

Some half a million Catholics and 450 priests in southern India have severed links with their apostolic administrator further escalating the five-decade-long liturgical dispute within the Eastern rite Syro-Malabar Church.

Officials of the Ernakulam-Angamaly Archdiocese based in the southern state of Kerala said the majority of Catholics and priests there have cut off official links with the Vatican-appointed administrator, Archbishop Andrews Thazhath.

The decision was taken at a meeting of some 250 priests in the Archbishop’s House on Oct. 18.

Archbishop Andrews Thazhath is “unfit for the position” and the archdiocesan priest will not report to him and obey his instructions on pastoral duties, said an official communication from Father Jose Vailikodath, senior priest and public relations officer of the Archdiocesan Protection Committee (of priests).

The priests in a resolution adopted said that “the administrator or his acolytes will not be invited to any parish or other Church-run institutions” and ended the practice of priests’ reporting to the Archbishop’s House on any matter related to the administration of parishes even those requiring the consent of the archbishop.

A canon law expert, who does not want to be quoted, said the development should be seen as “a very serious move that would have an unexpected impact on the priests.”

“It amounts to severing links with the hierarchy and defying the papal authority. These are very serious violations. I’m not sure if the priests are acting with the kind of awareness they should show here,” he said requesting not to publish his name.

This dramatic turn of events took place after Archbishop Andrews Thazhath, the apostolic administrator entered the Archbishop’s House on the night of Oct. 17 with the help of the police force following an open threat from the laypeople that they would not allow him to enter it for his alleged betrayal.

They had earlier launched a round-the-clock vigil around the Archbishop’s House with effect from Oct. 16.

When the priests got to know that the administrator entered the Archbishop’s House with the help of police, they rushed there and demanded the procurator who summoned the police at the instruction of Archbishop Thazhath to withdraw the force.

The priests also threatened to stay put in the Archbishop’s House until the police force was finally withdrawn under pressure.

Meanwhile, the priests also passed a resolution announcing a permanent boycott of Archbishop Thazhath and his supporters with immediate effect. They also condemned the action of the administrator to turn the Archbishop’s House into a “police raj” (police rule).

The priests further decided to discontinue the parish contributions to the Archdiocese, not share any information about the parish with the archbishop (administrator) nor take any order from him, says Father Vailikodath.

The issues that required the permission of the archbishop, the priest said in a statement, “would be decided at the Forane level” deepening the ongoing tug of war between the archdiocese and the synod of the Syro-Malabar Church over the decades-long Mass dispute in the Archdiocese.

The liturgical dispute dates back nearly five decades when the Church initiated a revision of its liturgy. The simmering controversy was revived in August 2021 when the synod decided to implement its 1999 decision of introducing uniformity in Mass across all the dioceses to bring in more unity among its members.

All 35 dioceses of the Church except in the Ernakulam-Angamaly Archdiocese have begun following the synod-approved mass from November last.

Archbishop Thazhath on Sept. 30 imposed the liturgical pattern approved by the bishops’ synod that requires priests to face the altar against the congregation during the Eucharistic prayer until Communion.

The prelate left the Archbishop’s House soon after this announcement with the help of police.  But the priests and the lay people in the archdiocese insisted on continuing with their traditional Mass, in which the celebrant faces the congregation throughout.

The priests and the lay people have accused Archbishop Thazhath of misleading the Vatican by hushing up the signed documents from parishes and more than 400 priests from the archdiocese in favor of the traditional Mass.

They also said that the prelate imposed the synod Mass in the archdiocese without consulting the canonical bodies even after assuring the lay people and the priests he would consult them.

The priests continued to offer Mass facing the congregation in total defiance of the order from the administrator.

The priests in their resolution said the administrator had not taken into confidence the views of 500,000 faithful and 450 priests in the archdiocese and vowed to discontinue all contact with him.

They also claimed that among the 460 priests in the archdiocese, 377 had signed the resolution to boycott the administrator while the remaining, barring 10 priests, had extended their support as they could not sign since they were away.

Riju Kanjookaran, the spokesperson of the Archdiocesan Movement for Transparency (AMT) told UCA News on Oct. 19: “We the people and the priests are together on this sensitive issue of Mass and will not make any compromise.”

The priests and the laity have appealed to the Vatican to grant a “liturgy variant” status to their traditional Mass and end the dispute in the spirit of the Second Vatican Council.

Father Antony Vadakkekara VC, the spokesperson of the Syro-Malabar Church, did not respond to calls and text messages from UCA News.

Many Church officials though said the lay people were worried due to the revolt by the priests and the laity leading to a breaking point.

The Ernakulam-Angamaly Archdiocese is the biggest diocese in the Syro-Malabar Church with more than half a million faithful, almost 10 percent of the 5.5 million people in the Eastern rite Church.

Help UCA News to be independent
Dear reader,
Lent is the season during which catechumens make their final preparations to be welcomed into the Church.
Each year during Lent, UCA News presents the stories of people who will join the Church in proclaiming that Jesus Christ is their Lord. The stories of how women and men who will be baptized came to believe in Christ are inspirations for all of us as we prepare to celebrate the Church's chief feast.
Help us with your donations to bring such stories of faith that make a difference in the Church and society.
A small contribution of US$5 will support us continue our mission…
William J. Grimm
UCA News

Share your comments

6 Comments on this Story
Congratulations for publishing the news of Ernakulam Angamaly Arch Diocese. The newly appointed apostolic administrator bp Thazhath behaving like Hitler. There was no consensus in the synod to change the holy mass practiced for the last 52 years facing the people. Some of the synod members wanted to change the mass facing the altar. They also wanted to remove the crucifix from altar and to instal manikeyan cross in the altar. The entire parishes more than 400 in numbers barring 4 wanted the holy mass facing the people and submitted written memorandum to Bp Thazhath. He manipulated the memorandum and interpreted that the parishioners wanted mass facing the altar. It is an utter lie and misrepresentation of the facts. He is threatening the priests and laities with dire consequences. With the help of the higher ups at the office of the eastern churches, Bp Thazhath and Bp Alanchery forcefully obtained the resignation of Metropolitan Vicar Bp Kariyil and forcefully sent him out of Ernakulam Angamaly Arch diocese with a dictum not to enter the boundaries of Ernakulam Angamaly Arch diocese. Due to the undue pressure he was ill and denied medical treatment stating the dictum. Further Bp Thazhath visited him and threatened him again,which made his health further deteriorated and needed hospitalization for about 2 months. These are the things happening in Ernakulam Angamaly Arch diocese. The faithful are united, we wanted the holy mass facing the people, we wanted the holy mass the way our holy father is practicing.
I think in this day and age, you should give a bit of credit to the holy Father. The idea that he doesn't know what's happening in the diocese is laughable. Your entire comment is full of lies spouted by the rebel priests and the laity associations supporting them. Archbishop Kariyil was asked to resign by the Vatican through the nuncio to India. The decision taken by the synod was only related to the mass. There was never any decrees or orders regarding sacramentals like the cross, et, which is left is entirely upto the discretion of each individual diocesan bishop. Either you are misled or you are purposely misstating facts. I hope for your sake, it's the first one.
I am the convener of a laity organisation called Mar Thoma Nasrani Sangham(MTNS) that stand with Syro Malabar Church and the Pope. And I agree with you that these dissident priests do not know what they are doing. Because it constitutes a revolt against The Pope himself. I hope you will show the same urge to get our side of the story too. The photo you published is a photo opportunity they did on last Sunday (16.10.2022).And Mar Thazhath arrived only on 17.10.2022 Monday no protester was there at Archbishop 's house. Please show your transparency by giving our version also. Thank you
How can this people be with Pope without obeying his orders, Rediculous
I pray for our Holy Church and the Pope that wisdom and understanding will prevail and that this unnecessary dispute will be solved amicably. God is Great!
There is no one type of Catholic or Catholic faith practices. Many stories in this website attest to this fact. It is best to hold a pluralist ethos in the Church, and not impose anything in the name of uniformity without proper consultation, consensus-building, transparency and an open channel of communication between the Vatican and the laity. Surely, we can all be Catholics at the core, despite the dissimilarities in our faith practices.
Asian Bishops
Latest News
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia