UCA News

Priest slams Indonesia ban on sex outside marriage

Father Otto Gusti Madung calls the move 'a setback to protecting the liberal rights of citizens'
Divine Word Father Otto Gusti Madung

Divine Word Father Otto Gusti Madung. (Photo supplied)

Published: December 07, 2022 11:16 AM GMT
Updated: December 07, 2022 12:20 PM GMT

An Indonesian Catholic priest has joined human rights activists in criticizing a new criminal code approved by Indonesia’s parliament that outlaws sex outside of marriage with a punishment of up to one year in jail.

Indonesia's criminal code, which stretches back to the Dutch colonial era, has been debated for decades and its lawmakers finally approved sweeping changes to it on Dec. 6, despite widespread opposition from civil society.

Divine Word Father Otto Gusti Madung, a lecturer at the Institute of Philosophy and Creative Technology in Flores, East Nusa Tenggara province, called the parliament’s decision “a setback to protecting the liberal rights of citizens which includes the guarantee of human dignity.”

He said the move was part of an effort to incorporate religious morality into the law.

The priest who teaches philosophy and human rights said it is a moral imperative that sex between two individuals may only be carried out after marriage according to the religion they follow.

However, sex outside of marriage is also a private moral issue that can be resolved by religions or individual personal moral considerations in the case of non-religious people and hence should not be regulated by civil laws, he added.

"When this religious morality is adopted into criminal affairs, the state is actually making religious morality a state issue," Father Madung told UCA News.

The priest said this clearly amounted to intervening in the private sphere of citizens. Sex is different from someone committing murder or stealing, he explained.

“If two individuals are free and autonomous to have sex outside of marriage, who is the victim, and who is harmed?” he asked.

He said the state must only get involved if in such sex "there is an unequal relationship, there is no consent from one of the parties involved in the relationship, or there is sexual exploitation."

The state must protect the rights of victims in such cases, he said.

“The assumption here is that it is the piety of the religious community that suffers. But which religion? Thus, its interpretation will depend on the interpretation of law enforcers. And the subjectivity of law enforcers opens up opportunities for arbitrariness or abuse of power," he warned.

Usman Hamid of Amnesty International Indonesia called the legislation “a significant blow to Indonesia’s hard-won progress in protecting human rights and fundamental freedoms over more than two decades.”

The fact that the Indonesian government and the House of Representatives agreed to pass a code that effectively stamps out many human rights is appalling, he said.

Hamid called the ban on sex outside of marriage "a violation of the right to privacy protected under international law.”

“Such ‘morality’ provisions could even potentially be misused to criminalize victims of sexual assault or to target members of the LGBTI community. Consensual sexual relationships should not be treated as a criminal offense or a violation of ‘morality,’” he added.

Eva Sundari, a former member of the Indonesian parliament and board member of ASEAN Parliamentarians for Human Rights, said in a statement that “by drafting these problematic articles and allowing them to pass, the Joko Widodo administration has failed to live up to the commitment to democracy and human rights that it has so often claimed to espouse.”

The very least that President Joko Widodo can do is open the possibility for changes and judicial reviews within the next three years before the new criminal code comes fully into effect, she added.

The government and parliament have responded to criticism from civil groups by suggesting they seek a judicial review in the Constitutional Court.

Adhitiya Augusta Triputra, who represents a civil society coalition, said the Constitutional Court has become “a kind of wastebasket, the rubbish of which are the policies made by the parliament.”

Help UCA News to be independent
Dear reader,
Trafficking is one of the largest criminal industries in the world, only outdone by drugs and arms trafficking, and is the fastest-growing crime today.
Victims come from every continent and are trafficked within and to every continent. Asia is notorious as a hotbed of trafficking.
In this series, UCA News introduces our readers to this problem, its victims, and the efforts of those who shine the light of the Gospel on what the Vatican calls “these varied and brutal denials of human dignity.”
Help us with your donations to bring such stories of faith that make a difference in the Church and society.
A small contribution of US$5 will support us continue our mission…
William J. Grimm
UCA News

Share your comments

5 Comments on this Story
The Priest is wrong !This Law will strengthen the moral Fibre of the nation.
This priest should be removed from the Church. He would be better as a priest of the church of the new world order.
I think you missed the essence of what the priest is saying--the difference between sin and crime. Religions should be bothered with sins, as the state should be with crimes. When a state legislates on the moral values of the religion, we allow the state to interpret the religion. What if the state considers only the morality of the dominant religion to interpret the law? It will lead to religious fascism--a real threat in several Asian nations.
This Judas priest probably just wants to avoid personal criminal penalties for keeping a mistress or engaging in homosexual behavior. He would be more deserving of respect if he were more directly honest about his rejection of Christ and contempt for God’s law.
I agree with the law and that the government does have the right and even the obligation for it. The explosion of single motherhood and children born out of wedlock is responsible for the collapse of society and the billions of taxpayer money spent on welfare, food stamps, and all sorts of free stuff.
Asian Bishops
Latest News
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia