Media was led in 'a certain direction' by Vatican insiders last year, Napier says
Cardinal Wilfrid F. Napier of Durban, South Africa, says a more open approach at the Synod of Bishops will reduce the fears of media manipulation. (CNS file photo)
Greater emphasis on small-group discussions and incorporating that work into the synod's final draft document is helping alleviate any suspicion of the synod being manipulated, said one of the four synod presidents.
Cardinal Wilfrid F. Napier of Durban, South Africa, told Catholic News Service Oct. 7, "I think this time we are aware of and I think the secretary of the synod (Cardinal Lorenzo Baldisseri) is aware that there are these suspicions and, therefore, I think there's going to be a much more perhaps openhanded approach to the synod."
Last year, Cardinal Napier had openly criticized the publication of a midterm report during the synod and the decision not to release summaries of the speeches participants gave in the synod hall. He and several other synod fathers at the time suggested that the midterm report did not accurately reflect the assembly's views and that the press had no way of assessing the report's accuracy.
Speaking to CNS on the sidelines of this year's synod, Cardinal Napier said he had found it "strange" last year that the media had been given a detailed midterm report before the issues facing the synod had been fully discussed.
This meant the media "were given a certain direction that could only have come from inside and, therefore, raised the suspicion — which I think is not quite as strongly present now as it was" in the year between the synods "that there was some manipulation going on," he said.
While summaries of speakers' presentations still are not distributed by the Vatican, Cardinal Baldisseri insisted bishops were free to give their texts to whomever they wanted.
In addition, Pope Francis created a 10-person committee to oversee the drafting of the final synod document and ensure it incorporates the general discussions, small groups' reports and written comments from synod participants.
Cardinal Napier said he has been pleased with the increased emphasis on and time given to the small group discussions, saying the bishops "have been given what we have always said is the best part" of a synod.
After just two days of meeting in the language-based groups, the cardinal said the discussions "have actually fulfilled my expectations. Really free and open exchanges, a real getting a good measure of what's happening in the church in the various parts of the world."
He said he thought that the input coming from the small groups was "already giving the draft document a direction which is rather difficult, I think, to work into a particular position."
Rather than being focused on one particular view or approach, he said, the small groups are discussing "what we believe is the direction in which the church in general wants to go."
When a final document is drawn up at the synod's end, he said, "certainly the result I am looking forward to is a document that we can put into people's hands," which will give them very clear direction as to the mission and vocation of today's families.
Unequal Christians of Asian Churches is a new series of features aimed to help us see prejudice and bias that are at work in our Church. They also help us see the struggles of Catholics to live out their faith.
Such features come to you for FREE, but it cost us to produce them.
Share your comments
The Roman Catholic Diocese of Wuzhou is a diocese located in the city of Wuzhou in
The Apostolic Prefecture of Jian'ou is a apostolic prefecture located in the city
Basilica of Our Lady of Graces in Sardhana is a historic church that lives the memory of love and...
St. Mary’s Cathedral Church in Ranchi, the capital of Jharkhand state, is the mother church in...
On every first Friday of the month thousands of Catholics flock to Holy Cross Church of Cherpunkal...