UCA News

Indian prelate claims no reason given for quit order

Archbishop Antony Kariyil was told to resign for failing to adopt synod-approved uniform Mass in Syro-Malabar Church
Archbishop Antony Kariyil, the former metropolitan vicar of Ernakulam-Angamaly Archdiocese, met Pope Francis in 2021 in the Vatican and explained the liturgical controversy.

Archbishop Antony Kariyil, the former metropolitan vicar of Ernakulam-Angamaly Archdiocese, met Pope Francis in 2021 in the Vatican and explained the liturgical controversy. (Photo:ernakulamarchdiocese.org)


Published: August 05, 2022 05:34 PM GMT

An Indian archbishop from the eastern rite Syro-Malabar Church who resigned last week amid a raging liturgical dispute has alleged he was forced from office without being given any reason by the papal representative to India

Archbishop Antony Kariyil, who resigned as the metropolitan vicar of Ernakulam-Angamaly Archdiocese in southern Kerala state, in an open letter on Aug. 3 also accused Vatican offices of mismanaging the five-decade-old liturgical dispute.

Archbishop Kariyil resigned amid allegations his archdiocese defied the Syro-Malabar Catholic Church's supreme synod in the liturgical dispute. He was summoned to New Delhi on July 19 by Archbishop Leopoldo Girelli, the apostolic nuncio to India, and told to tender his resignation within 24 hours.

In an open letter addressed to priests and the laity, Archbishop Kariyil said: “Since this was an important decision concerning the archdiocese and my life, I requested in writing to have a week to reply. But the nuncio refused. He informed me that if I failed to resign, a process would be started to sack me.”

The prelate said he handed over a letter addressed to Pope Francis and returned to Kerala. A week later, on July 26, the nuncio visited him and said his request seeking reasons for the resignation was communicated to Rome.

But he was told that “for the good of the Church" the pope is demanding his resignation. Archbishop Kariyil said he then resigned in obedience to the pope.

“I was aware that my decision to protect the interests of the faithful would cost me dearly"

His resignation came amid a raging controversy over the refusal of the archdiocesan priests and laity to accept a liturgical structure formulated by the synod, according to which the Mass celebrant turns to the altar during the Eucharistic prayer.

The archdiocesan priests refused to accept this saying they want to continue facing the congregation throughout the Mass.

“I was aware that my decision to protect the interests of the faithful would cost me dearly,” Archbishop Kariyil said in his six-page letter written in his native Malayalam.

The synod granted dispensation to the archdiocese from implementing its decision with approval from Pope Francis and the Prefect of the Oriental Congregation Cardinal Leonardo Sandri.

Still, his decision was treated as defiance against the synod, Archbishop Kariyil rued.

“I could have protected my office by issuing an order to implement the synod’s decision... but I considered my conscience and the spiritual well-being of the believers,” he further claimed in the letter.

"The synod’s insistence on liturgical uniformity complicated issues"

The former metropolitan vicar recalled he took charge of the post at the Ernakulam-Angamaly Archdiocese in 2019 in the midst of criminal court cases and controversies related to dubious Church land deals allegedly involving the Eastern Church’s head, Archbishop George Alencherry.

The synod created the office of archdiocesan vicar without consulting the canonical bodies of the archdiocese, he said adding that he took up the responsibility as a member of the archdiocese expecting people’s cooperation. 

Archbishop Kariyil took office as the priests and laity demanded the resignation of Cardinal Alencherry.

The synod’s insistence on liturgical uniformity complicated issues and destroyed to a great extent the peace and unity in the Church, Archbishop Kariyil said.

The decision to implement a uniform mass for liturgical unity in August 2020 came when the land controversies and court cases were at their peak, and it further divided the Church.

“The pastoral orientation” of the people of the archdiocese was communicated to the Vatican Oriental Congregation, Vatican state secretary, and Vatican nuncio in India.

"I also spoke to Pope Francis in person and wrote letters on other occasions. But they all took the stand that the synodal decision is final and needs to be followed,” Archbishop Kariyil said.

Archbishop Kariyil has been replaced by Archbishop Andrews Thazhath, an expert in the Eastern Catholic Code of Canon Law, and is reportedly tasked to end the dispute and ensure liturgical unity in the Church headquartered in Kerala.

When contacted, the Vatican nunciature in New Delhi refused to comment on the open letter and suggested sending queries by email. But there was no response so far to the questions posed by UCA News.

Help UCA News to be independent
Dear reader,
Lent is the season during which catechumens make their final preparations to be welcomed into the Church.
Each year during Lent, UCA News presents the stories of people who will join the Church in proclaiming that Jesus Christ is their Lord. The stories of how women and men who will be baptized came to believe in Christ are inspirations for all of us as we prepare to celebrate the Church's chief feast.
Help us with your donations to bring such stories of faith that make a difference in the Church and society.
A small contribution of US$5 will support us continue our mission…
William J. Grimm
UCA News

Share your comments

8 Comments on this Story
I can give him over 100 reasons ????
Wish to see 99 reasons
The ousted Bishop Kariyil who been leading the rebels thinks he is superior to all the other 64 Bishops who actually have Higher qualifications either in theology or Canon laws ???? He is only a specialist in Management with no specialisation either in cannon laws or theology ????And it was the root cause for his destruction ???? The rogue priests of Ernakulam and their minions whose main work is to protest and abuse Church authorities believe they're superior to all the others who work hard in other 34 dioceses ????
Antony Kariyil did the best for the people of God of Ernakulam-Ankamaly diocese. He is one of the best Shepherds Syro Malabar church ever had.
Was Jesus Christ a theologian, or took doctorate in cannon law. I think He never asked to rule he asked to be the servant and good Shepherd
The root cause of the issue is real estate fraud that Cardinal George Alencherry, the head of the church did. Complaints went to Vatican and different internal and external agencies including KPMG investigated and audited the transactions. They found the arch diocese lost 300 million Indian rupees due to the fraud deals of the cardinal. Vatican ordered to reimburse the money lost to the arch diocese. Cardinal George is creating other issues to divert the attention of the public from the land scandal. The archbishop karial who resigned now actually is very nice person who refused to support the manipulations of the land scandal Cardinal George Alencherry.
You are right trying to cover up the money matter with liturgical issues
The forced resignation of Archbishop Kariyil has been a most uncalled for event in the Church in Kerala considering the facts behind the liturgical controversy. It obviously goes against the tenets of synodality that has been in vogue since Pope Francis introduced it as the manner of running the Church.It has been a grave act of injustice done to a man who sought to abide by the principles of Vatican II concerning the liturgy. If a section of Syro-Malabar Church wants to hold on to traditions and refuses to implement changes in litury that make sense in the light of the Incarnation in Christ, the Vatican offices concerned ought to study the matter more deeply and feel the pulse of the affected people who are by and large ignorant of the complexities of the Syrian liturgy by the very fact that it is blocked out of their view in most dioceses. The decision made by the body of bishops who are pressurized by some external forces or unknown agenda rather than following the mind of Christ, cannot be accepted as the will of the people of God belonging to the Syro-Malabar rite.
Asian Bishops
Latest News
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia