UCA News


Indian court stops minority medical schools selecting students

Christians say the Supreme Court ruling infringes their right to manage institutions

UCA News reporter

UCA News reporter

Updated: May 02, 2020 05:45 AM GMT
Support Asia's largest network of Catholic journalists and editors
Support Asia's largest network of Catholic journalists and editors
Indian court stops minority medical schools selecting students

St. John’s Medical College in Bengaluru used to hold its own entrance exam. (Photo: Wikimapia)

Share this article :
Medical schools run by religious minorities such as Christians and Muslims do not have the right to admit students independently from the national process of admission, India’s Supreme Court has ruled.

The top court’s ruling on April 29 comes after eight-year-long litigation in which 76 institutions, most of them Christian, argued that they have a right to admit students of their choice.

The Supreme Court said all medical schools in the country should admit students for medical degrees only through the merit list of an eligibility test called the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET).

The litigation started in 2012 when the federal government made NEET mandatory for medical schools to admit students. Minority-run institutions challenged it as a violation of their constitutional right.

The Indian constitution guarantees religious and linguistic minorities the right to establish and manage institutions for the betterment of their communities. Petitioners said this includes a right to admit students of their choice.

The court said the constitutional right is “not violated by provisions for the uniform entrance examination to all medical educational institutions under undergraduate level and postgraduate level through such designated authority.”

Christian leaders believe the order limits their rights.

“We cannot now admit a student for medical degree courses if he or she has not cleared the NEET,” said Father Paul Parathazham, director of St. John’s Medical College in Bengaluru, run by the Catholic Bishops' Conference of India.

The church-run medical college used to hold its own eligibility examination “in a very transparent way to select students for a medical degree. But now it is no more possible,” Father Parathazham told UCA News on May 1.

St. John’s was among the petitioners but withdrew following a state court order that forced it to admit students from the NEET merit list, the priest said.

He said its selection criteria were “not just academic brilliance or caliber. We also considered their aptitude to serve in remote villages of India, where medical care is almost non-existent.”

The medical college, opened 45 years ago, has trained some 300 Catholic nuns as doctors who now serve in remote villages of India.

“The purpose of establishing our medical college was for serving the poor. Now, with this order, such consideration has no merit,” the priest added.

Father Ajay Singh, a lawyer and activist priest based in Odisha in eastern India, said the order is “also a big blow to the poor Dalit and tribal Christians who need special consideration in admission to such professional colleges.”

Students from rich families “spend a lot of money to go for coaching to gain top grades in NEET. The poor cannot compete with them,” Father Singh said.

However, the education commission of Indian bishops has no plans to challenge the judges’ order, said its secretary, Salesian Father Joseph Manipadam.

The court highlighted malpractices in the selection of students for medical admission as significant grounds to approve a single unified process for admitting students. 

Support UCA News...

As 2020 unfolds, we are asking readers like you to help us keep Union of Catholic Asian News (UCA News) free so it can be accessed from anywhere in the world at no cost.

That has been our policy for years and was made possible by donations from European Catholic funding agencies. However, like the Church in Europe, these agencies are in decline and the immediate and urgent claims on their funds for humanitarian emergencies in Africa and parts of Asia mean there is much less to distribute than there was even a decade ago.

Forty years ago, when UCA News was founded, Asia was a very different place - many poor and underdeveloped countries with large populations to feed, political instability and economies too often poised on the edge of collapse. Today, Asia is the economic engine room of the world and funding agencies quite rightly look to UCA News to do more to fund itself.

UCA News has a unique product developed from a view of the world and the Church through informed Catholic eyes. Our journalistic standards are as high as any in the quality press; our focus is particularly on a fast-growing part of the world - Asia - where, in some countries the Church is growing faster than pastoral resources can respond to - South Korea, Vietnam and India to name just three.

And UCA News has the advantage of having in its ranks local reporters that cover 22 countries and experienced native English-speaking editors to render stories that are informative, informed and perceptive.

We report from the ground where other news services simply can't or won't go. We report the stories of local people and their experiences in a way that Western news outlets simply don't have the resources to reach. And we report on the emerging life of new Churches in old lands where being a Catholic can at times be very dangerous.

With dwindling support from funding partners in Europe and the USA, we need to call on the support of those who benefit from our work.

Click here to find out the ways you can support UCA News. You can make a difference for as little as US$5...
UCAN Donate
Thank you. You are now signed up to our Daily Full Bulletin newsletter
Support UCA News

William J. Grimm, MM


Union of Catholic Asian News

"As Pope Francis has said, we live not so much in an era of change as in a change of era. That is especially true in Asia and for the churches of Asia. UCA News is the dedicated, Asia-wide news and information service for the Church in Asia and we need your help to maintain the service."