Rape accuser, Kerala state say the prosecution has a strong case against Bishop Franco Mulakkal
A file photo of Bishop Franco Mulakkal of Jalandhar taken in 2017. (Photo: UCA News)
Indian Bishop Franco Mulakkal’s acquittal in a rape case by a trial court has been challenged by his accuser and the Kerala government in the southern state’s high court.
The accuser, a former superior general of the Missionaries of Jesus congregation, moved the high court on March 28 while the Kerala government filed its appeal through additional public prosecutor P. Narayanan on March 30.
On Jan. 14, Additional District and Sessions Judge G. Gopakumar cleared Bishop Mulakkal of all charges including rape and unnatural sex, saying the prosecution had failed to prove them.
The court also declared the complainant nun an unreliable witness in dismissing the case, which Bishop Mulakkal and those supporting him hailed as a victory for the Catholic Church.
Kerala state, in its appeal to the high court, has sought that the lower court’s decision be kept aside as it was “patently wrong, manifestly erroneous and totally perverse.”
The nun's testimony was corroborated with witness statements and other documentary evidence but the trial court failed to appreciate them as per the laid-down laws in the country, especially the orders from the Supreme Court of India and other high courts, the state argued.
The trial court also did not appreciate the vulnerability of the nun, especially in a case where she was in a fiduciary relationship with the accused
The accused bishop, the prosecution stated, was present in the Kuravilangad convent in Kerala’s Kottayam district, where the alleged offenses took place, on all the days his accuser was raped and forced into unnatural sex.
Meanwhile, the nun said in her appeal that the trial court had deliberately ignored the testimonies of her and other witnesses supporting her and had cast aspersions on them to favor the accused.
The trial court also did not appreciate the vulnerability of the nun, especially in a case where she was in a fiduciary relationship with the accused.
The nun belonged to a diocesan congregation under the patronage of the Bishop Mulakkal, whom she accused of raping her 13 times from 2014 to 2016.
Bishop Mulakkal denied all the charges and was acquitted.
The prelate tried to escape the trial by seeking a discharge from the case but his request was denied by the courts – from the lowest court up to the Supreme Court
The special police team that probed the case had filed a 2,000-page charge sheet that charged him with wrongful confinement, rape, unnatural sex and criminal intimidation.
The prelate tried to escape the trial by seeking a discharge from the case but his request was denied by the courts –- from the lowest court up to the Supreme Court.
He continues to be the bishop of Jalandhar Diocese, though he does not hold any administrative powers as he voluntarily sought leave from the Vatican to enable him to fight the rape case.
His supporters demanded his reinstatement after acquittal by the lower court but his accuser and those backing her opposed any such move as long as the legal option for appealing the decision existed.
Bishop Mulakkal has begun taking classes of priests and making appearances at public functions.
Unequal Christians of Asian Churches is a new series of features aimed to help us see prejudice and bias that are at work in our Church. They also help us see the struggles of Catholics to live out their faith.
Such features come to you for FREE, but it cost us to produce them.
Share your comments
Lingling, the former name of Yongzhou, is one of two urban districts of Yongzhou City, Hunan
With a land area of 67,482 square kilometers, the eparchy covers the districts of Nilgiris in Tamil Nadu state; Mysore,
St. Francis Xavier Church in the China town of former Vietnamese capital Saigon (Ho Chi Minh City)...
St. John’s Church in Kuala Belait of westernmost Brunei carries the legacy of two Spanish...
Asian Catholics who cannot travel to Italy to venerate the relics of Padre Pio now has an...