UCA News
Jesuit Father Myron J. Pereira, based in Mumbai, has spent more than five decades as an academic, journalist, editor and writer of fiction. He contributes regularly to UCA News on religious and socio-cultural topics.
Falling priest-bishop trust remains hierarchy’s sad story
A recent survey of American priests shows the perpetual risk of stress and ‘burnout’
October 24, 2022 03:56 AM GMT

October 24, 2022 04:15 AM GMT

For almost every Catholic family of yesteryear, having a son as a priest, or a daughter as a nun was a source of pride. Why is it that vocations to the Catholic priesthood no longer attract as they once did?

It is a complex question with many answers.

Some of the reasons are demographic: families today are smaller, and parents are reluctant to see an only son (or daughter) pursue a celibate vocation in the Church. After all, the desire for physical posterity is strong everywhere.

Besides, today's employment opportunities are many and far more attractive than in former times. It used to be that the priest was the only educated person in town and his advice was sought on everything that mattered.  No longer. Many others today, both men and women, are far better educated and professionally competent than he.

Earlier cultures were feudal and traditionally religious. This means that priests and nuns were accorded a measure of respect and privilege in society.

But as societies become “secularized,” their socio-economic and “this-worldly” values spread and take hold. Far less do spiritual and “otherworldly” values motivate human behavior.

"Changes in contemporary society have indeed impinged upon vocations to the priesthood and religious life"

Or in simpler words, wherever TV comedies displace the family rosary and evening prayer at home, it’s not likely that priesthood or religious life will have any aspirational value at all.

And most of all, today financial success supersedes almost every other value.

So changes in contemporary society have indeed impinged upon vocations to the priesthood and religious life.

But there are also important factors from within that make priesthood or religious life a less than attractive option. These must be faced squarely, and with humility.

Perhaps the first of these is that the Church lives in a ‘time warp’ all her own.

What is a time warp? Simply put, it means being fixed in the past which offers comfort and security, and denies the actuality of the turbulent, unpredictable present.

"The canonical obligations of religious life were perceived as stifling and were rejected in their entirety"

Sometimes it’s a war or a revolution that inflicts traumatic rupture upon individuals or communities.  The French Revolution did this in Europe two hundred years ago. Today, even decades after the collapse of the Soviet Union, many look back at those times with nostalgia and longing.

A time warp makes it convenient to revert to an age where everything was familiar, safe and respected.

Undoubtedly the most turbulent event in the Church of the last 60 years was the Second Vatican Council (1962-65). It broke with centuries of hidebound tradition and an imperial papacy, and ushered in an “open Church”.

The loyal foot soldiers of the Church had always been its dedicated clergy, both diocesan and religious, and thousands of nuns, the mainstay of its educational and welfare system.

Now to the consternation of many, these left in droves. They “gave up their vocations” and made other options, personal choices.

For such as these, it was the experience of freedom that the Council brought. The canonical obligations of religious life were perceived as stifling and were rejected in their entirety — the repressive obligations of celibacy, particularly.

So what really is meant by an “open Church?” 

Perhaps the quickest definition was given some years ago by Pope Francis: a Church that is “open to mercy,” and the understanding of human weakness, which is slow to condemn and ostracize, and always ready to accept and forgive.

Francis’s metaphor — a “field hospital” was the most apt description of the Church’s mission.

Earlier, before the council, the Church was quite different. Those who exercised power within it called it a “perfect society.” With the sense of entitlement that most bishops and priests have, they lorded it over ordinary Catholics. Today we know this attitude as ‘clericalism.’

"It moves away from a juridical definition of vocation towards an evangelical, Gospel-based understanding"

It has been responsible for much of the corruption in the Church.

It is the very opposite of dialogue, which Pope Paul VI called “the new way of being church.” He could very well have called it ‘openness.’

Paul even elaborated four ways to engage in dialogue — by living and working together, through study and prayer; and asked that the Church dialogue not just with the world’s religions, but also with secularism and Marxism as a sign of its openness.

Admittedly, it’s been hard for a Church more inclined to condemn than to understand, be it other religions or other customs and ideologies.

Sixty years after the council, it’s still difficult and not practiced enough.

An open Church redefines priesthood and religious life. Most significantly perhaps, it moves away from a juridical definition of vocation towards an evangelical, Gospel-based understanding.

It asks, what did Jesus want his disciples to be?  How did he guide them?

A recent survey of American priests (2022) discovered that although most expressed much satisfaction about their way of life, the risk of stress and “burnout” remained always present.

One reason for this was the ever-present danger of false allegations against priests related to child sexual abuse.

But what was most saddening was that most priests cannot confide in their bishops, or look to them for support. They would rather lean on their parishioners and lay friends for help in a crisis. In fact, levels of trust between priests and bishops are steadily falling, a sad commentary on the hierarchy.

We’re far from being an open Church, true. Still, until a minimum of honesty and dialogue is reached, and at every level, more priests, women and young people will seek the freedom they desire elsewhere.

*The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official editorial position of UCA News.

Help UCA News to be independent
Dear reader,
November begins with the Feast of All Saints. That month will mark the beginning of a new UCA News series, Saints of the New Millenium, that will profile some of Asia’s saints, “ordinary” people who try to live faithfully amid the demands of life in our time.
Perhaps the closest they will ever come to fame will be in your reading about them in UCA News. But they are saints for today. Let their example challenge and encourage you to live your own sainthood.
Your contribution will help us present more such features and make a difference in society by being independent and objective.
A small donation of US$5 a month would make a big difference in our quest to achieve our goals.
William J. Grimm
UCA News
4 Comments on this Story
A new way of being Church requires a change in the structure. You cannot put new wine into old wineskins.. Unless the structures change nothing can change!!
Priesthood is not an employment but a commitment. A response to a call-John15:16 This call entails a grace [2 Cor 12:9] that provides sufficient support for the priest to serve His people-John 21:15. The priest needs to serve if and only if he loves God; lives the un-natural life [the vows] the weak human that he is and has opted for. The dearth of vocations to the priesthood is due to the lack of the above mentioned conditions and the entry to the priesthood without such a motivation. Hence, God does not call! Will the CEO of a company recruit employees who do not work?
Well expressed. It's a sociological reality. We must also admit that when we laity say exactly the same thing we are quickly labelled as anti-church!!
Priesthood is not for running business with business tag such as Director/Assistant Director etc. of any business institutions. It is profession to preach spirituality. Additional burden of administrating business, Priests do not have enough time for preaching spirituality and deviating from actual job of a Priest.
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia