UCA News

Christians criticize caning of first non-Muslim in Aceh

Elderly Protestant woman receives 28 strokes after being found guilty under controversial criminal code

Christians criticize caning of first non-Muslim in Aceh

Two sharia policewomen help a woman after she received a caning for breaking Islamic law during a public punishment in Banda Aceh, Indonesia, on March 1. (Photo by AFP)

Published: April 15, 2016 09:08 AM GMT

Updated: April 15, 2016 09:17 AM GMT

Protestant and Catholic leaders have criticized the first-ever caning of a non-Muslim in Indonesia's Aceh province.

Semi-autonomous Aceh implemented Shariah, or Islamic law, in 2001.

Remita Sinaga, 60, a member of the Batak Protestant Church was publically whipped 28 times with a rattan cane in Central Aceh district on April 12.

Ucan Store
Ucan Store

She was found guilty by a Shariah court in Takengon, the district capital, of breaching a newly introduced Islamic criminal code or qanun hukum jinayat by selling alcohol.

She also spent 47 days in detention during the trial process.

The new criminal code, which took effect on Oct. 23 last year, stipulates harsh punishments, including caning, for offenses such as homosexuality, drinking alcohol, gambling, adultery, sexual harassment and rape.

Christian leaders have spoken out against the caning, saying Shariah does not include Christians and that the new Muslim criminal code is being used against everyone, regardless of religion.  

"We don't defend her [Sinaga]. Our concern is that the law isn't in line with the national penal code. What we understood is that Shariah law is only supposed to be for Muslims," the Rev. Betty Manurung of the Batak Protestant Church in Takengon, told ucanews.com April 15.

"However, the situation isn't like that," she said.

"Information I got from an official at the court is that qanun hukum jinayat is for all people living in Aceh."

This has raised fears among Christians, she said.

Father Paulus Christian Siswantoko, executive secretary of the Catholic bishops' Commission for Justice, Peace and Pastoral for Migrant-Itinerant People, said caning should only be applied, if at all, to Muslims adhering to Islamic law.

Criticizing the Aceh government, he said all people from different religious backgrounds should be treated fairly.

"Jakarta has allowed Aceh to implement Shariah law. But never force this law down the throats of other religions," he said.

Woro Wahyuningtyas, executive director of the Network of Christian Social Ministry Institutions in Indonesia, condemned all canings.

In an April 15 statement she called on the central government to review the Islamic criminal code, maintaining that "discriminative bylaws are against the constitution."

Syahrizal Abbas, head of Aceh's provincial Shariah agency, said Islamic law is principally applied only to Muslims. However, it can be applied to non-Muslims if they are caught violating it and willing to be sentenced under it.

“So if a non-Muslim is willing to be sentenced based on Shariah, then Shariah cannot refuse it,” he told ucanews.com

He said he did not know for sure whether the old woman was willing to be sentenced under Shariah.











Share your comments

Latest News

Ucanews Store

Read articles from La Croix International

UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia