UCA News

Cardinals' letter to pope raises concern at synod

Francis has responded to procedural issues raised, Vatican spokesman says

Cardinals' letter to pope raises concern at synod

Cardinal Wilfrid Napier of Durban, South Africa, is among a group of cardinals who wrote a letter to Pope Francis questioning procedural elements of the Synod of Bishops on the family. (Photo by CNS)

Published: October 14, 2015 05:49 AM GMT

Updated: October 13, 2015 07:48 PM GMT

From newspaper headlines and social media comments Oct. 12 it seemed there was a family feud going on inside the Synod of Bishops on the family.

Some cardinals — apparently 13 of the 74 cardinals participating in the synod — wrote Pope Francis a private letter expressing concern about a part or parts of the synod procedure, especially the appointment of a 10-member committee to draft the final document the synod will vote on and give to the pope. The names of the cardinals signing the letter changed over the course of the day, with four declaring they did not sign any letter and two others saying the leaked letter published by Italian blogger Sandro Magister is not the letter they signed.

In addition Oct. 13, Cardinal Norberto Rivera Carrera of Mexico City issued a statement saying, "I never signed the alleged letter with the attributed content that some mention."

Ucan Store
Ucan Store

"I recognize that the appropriate place of discussion is with other synod fathers and under the guide of the pope, who is our guarantor of unity in the church and who has my utmost respect and loyalty," Cardinal Rivera added.

The synod is supposed to be a process true to the Greek roots of the word meaning "walking together." Perhaps more than a family feud, what happened in mid-October was a family walk. Anyone with a big family — or even with just a couple very young members — knows how hard it is to keep everyone moving at the same pace and on the same trail with no arguments over rest stops or detours.

Australian Archbishop Mark Coleridge of Brisbane, writing on his blog, said the whole letter to-do was a "typically Roman melodrama, not untinged with psychodrama."

Jesuit Father Federico Lombardi, Vatican spokesman, said concern expressed in a private letter — not Magister's leaked and published "letter" — that Australian Cardinal George Pell and South Africa Wilfrid F. Napier said they sent the pope were addressed by Pope Francis and by Cardinal Lorenzo Baldisseri, the synod general secretary, first thing in the morning Oct. 6.

In his comments that morning, Pope Francis insisted Catholic doctrine on marriage has not been touched or put into question, Father Lombardi told reporters at the time, and he asked the synod "not to give into a 'hermeneutic of conspiracy,' which is sociologically weak and spiritually unhelpful."

Jesuit Father Antonio Spadaro, a synod member appointed by the pope, tweeted that day that Pope Francis encouraged a "profound discernment" in order "to understand how the Lord wants his church."

Pope Francis gestures as he talks with Bishop Fabio Fabene, under-secretary of the Synod of Bishops, and Cardinal Lorenzo Baldisseri, general secretary of the synod, before a session of the Synod of Bishops on the family at the Vatican. (Photo by CNS)


Cardinal Pell told the news site Vatican Insider Oct. 13 that he was "fundamentally satisfied" with the pope's response.

Father Lombardi told reporters that publishing the letter, or some form of it, a week after the pope responded to the cardinals' concerns was an "act of disturbance not intended by the signatories — or at least of the most authoritative among them."

"It is not surprising" that questions were raised about the new synod method, which gives more time to small group work and having them amend the working document rather than write a list of propositions for the pope, Father Lombardi said. But once the pope decided how he wanted things done, it was time for synod members to get to work, "which is what is happening."


Share your comments

Latest News

Ucanews Store
Asian Dioceses
Asian Pilgrim Centers
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia
UCA News Catholic Dioceses in Asia