UCAN needs your support
You are why we do what we do - report, describe, comment, review. It is to bring to your eyes just what life is like for believers across Asia that we publish UCAN.
But as you know, the effort needs to be sustained if it is to have continuing effect.
UCAN publishes some 150 stories a week in four languages across six websites. We are grateful to benefactors in Europe and the US who support us. But those countries and the Church there are under increasing financial strain and their generosity no longer covers our costs.
We need financial help from our readers to sustain our efforts. Our reporters, editors, video producers and photographers all have families and we need to support them. They do excellent jobs, but they can't do their jobs for nothing.
Will you help us to sustain UCAN? Please click here to help.
Thanks in anticipation.
Fr. Michael Kelly SJ
Why not try a taste of hudud law
It may not be a good idea but as Christians we should let Muslims give it a test drive
- Bishop Paul Tan Chee Ing, Johor Bahru
- September 30, 2011
This is because a general election is imminent and we are witnessing another edition of the perennial battle in Malaysian politics between the ruling and dominant political party, UMNO (United Malays National Organisation), and its nemesis, PAS (Pan-Malaysian Islamic Party).
Hudud is the part of Islamic sharia law that relates to prescribed punishments for assorted offences. There is a whole gamut of it provided for in Islamic jurisprudence. The goal is to ensure justice.
Kelantan state, in the northeastern corner of peninsular Malaysia, occupies a unique niche in Malaysian politics. Its voters have often bucked the electoral trend of most of the rest of the nation by voting for governments that are at odds with the ruling coalition.
The Kelantanese Muslims take great pride in projecting their state as â€śSerambi Mekah,â€ť which means â€śCorridor to Mecca.â€ť They have had in the last 21 years a chief minister who is truly a unique leader, Nik Aziz Nik Mat. He is the spiritual leader of PAS and has constantly espoused sharia for Muslims.
Try as they might, UMNO cannot deflate him because after 21 years in power, there is not a taint of corruption to his name. His spotless record is a tour de force in Malaysian politics, in splendid contrast to the moral squalor that characterizes UMNO politicians.
Since the general election is expected to be held soon, a dangerous battle is again playing out. The side that can say they are implementing sharia and its hudud aspects is assuredly the â€śholierâ€ť side because no Muslim can deny that it is ideal to live under a sharia-governed system. Nik Aziz is once again plumbing for sharia and hudud in Kelantan because it gives him tremendous stature in the run-up to the general election, but he also assures non-Muslims that it will not be implemented on them.
My position is that hudud is not a good idea for Malaysia.Â Nevertheless, I support implementing sharia and the hudud aspects of it for Muslims in Kelantan. I say that because Catholic teaching says, in Pope Benedict XVIâ€™s words, that â€śreligious freedom is the most fundamental aspect of human freedom, which is built into the dignity of being human.â€ť
Therefore we are bound to respect the beliefs of others. We should not oppose sharia for Muslims in Kelantan as long as non-Muslims have iron-clad guarantees it will not be implemented on them. It is time for all Malaysians to see how shariâ€™a operates in Kelantan and whether or not Muslims really like it.
No amount of telling Malaysian Muslims that the way it has been implemented in Saudi Arabia, Iran, Pakistan, Sudan and Afghanistan under the Taliban would hold a neutral observer back from recommending it to others. But you cannot win the argument against an ideological mindset that substitutes theoretical constructs for descriptions of the real world.
Therefore implementing hudud in Kelantan would be part of the whole exercise in self-discovery for Malaysians. As long as they have the unfettered right to vote in general elections, implementing hudud would ultimately be subject to the electoral verdict. And that is the ultimate assurance: that this system would not enjoy sustained tenure if it should be found gravely wanting.
Let us all see what the practical effects of its implementation are and whether or not Kelantanese Muslims like what they would get, and whether the rest of Malaysiaâ€™s Muslims like what they see.
Jesuit Bishop Paul Tan Chee Ing of Melaka-Johor is president of the Catholic bishopsâ€™ conference in Malaysia.