Tradition trumps Church teachings

Thousands of Filipinos ignore bishops' pleas to stop self-harm and crucifixions to mark Holy Week
Bernardino Balabo, Julian Labores and D'jay Lazaro, Manila
Philippines
April 23, 2011
Catholic Church News Image of Tradition trumps Church teachings
The crucifixion is re-enacted at Santa Cruz church in Bangkok using a statue of Christ but in the Philippines there is no shortage of volunteers for the role Photograph ©Michael Coyne

Tradition seems to have won out over Church teachings in the observance of Holy Week in the Philippines.

Church leaders repeatedly advised the faithful against the traditional corporal punishment and crucifixion re-enactments that mark the occassion. But thousands of Filipinos refused to listen and whipped themselves on the streets of villages around the country.

Some carry wooden crosses, others whipped themselves with lashes including blades. inflicting wounds to their backs under the scorching summer sun. Others even crawled through the streets while being kicked and whipped by friends.

The real crowd-puller, however, is the annual crucifixion rites in the provinces of Bulacan and Pampanga, north of the capital Manila.

Alexie Dionisio, 33, and Amparo “Mother Paring” Santos, 70, both said the annual crucifixion rites is the “will of God.”

Dionisio, who was first nailed on the cross when he was 15, said he received “divine messages” telling him to be crucified and to deliver the message of “God the Father.”

Mother Paring, meanwhile, said: “It was not my will, it was God’s will.” She also claimed to have received “divine messages” while hanging on the cross.

Church leaders, however, are not convinced.

The Catholic Bishop Conference of the Philippines (CBCP) said there is no need for corporal punishment to show one’s faith.

Church officials have advised the faithful to go to confession, pray, and meditate on Jesus Christ’s suffering, death and resurrection.

Archbishop Angel Lagdameo of Jaro discouraged self-flagellation and crucifixions, saying that the practices are an “imperfect imitation with doubtful theological and social significance.”

He said there is only one crucifixion – that of Christ – that saved mankind.

Bishop Pablo Virgilio David of Pampanga said lack of catechesis might have contributed to the practice of folk religiosity.

“We have to admit humbly that we have not catechized our people enough,” said Bishop David, who also heads the CBCP Commission on Biblical Apostolate.

He said most of those who get themselves crucified or those who hurt themselves are the “unchurched” or “the type who are baptized but would rarely come to church.”

Meanwhile, as thousands flocked to the provinces for the long Easter break which began on Thursday, President Benigno Aquino III reminded Filipinos to reflect on Christ’s death and resurrection and “to repay this through charitable work, and by helping in bearing the cross of the poor.”

In his Lenten message, the president said his administration is making sacrifices to implement much needed reforms, and no “Herod” can stop the administration from treading the right path.

“As long as we match our prayers with hard work, as long as we are united in sharing the burden of the nation, as long as we are focused on the welfare of the majority and not of self, no hardship, no Herod can stop us from pursuing our envisioned reforms,” President Aquino said.

In Baclaran district in Manila, some 100 Philippine Airlines workers staged their own “calvary” outside the Redemptorist church in Baclaran district.

“The threat of mass layoff and labor contractualization are heavy crosses for employees to bear,” said Gerry Rivera, president of the airline union.

Some workers carried makeshift crosses while being whipped by colleagues who were wearing masks of government and airline officials.

The workers later joined members of families of missing activists who were calling on the government for help to locate their loved ones.

Meanwhile, the CBCP’s online “Visita Iglesia” or church visit has become a big hit with nearly 60,000 visits on Maundy Thursday.

Traffic to the site climbed on Good Friday and Saturday and was expected even to increase on Easter Sunday.

Last year’s version crashed several times during the Holy Week due to the large number of visitors.

The CBCP launched this year’s “Visita Iglesia” site on April 1 for overseas Filipino workers who could not make it home and for Catholics who cannot physically make the traditional church visit.

647 words
 
  • Fr Sean Coyle

    I have been in the Philippines since 1971. I have never encountered people scourging or whipping themselves in the areas of Mindanao and the Visayas where I have lived nor have I heard anyone talking about such things. The events the story refers to take place in very few places and involve a tiny percentage of the country’s Catholic population of more than 70,000,000.

    It is true that the majority of Catholics are poorly catechized but these bizarre events, especially the ‘crucifixions’, are not a reflection of the faith of the Philippine people. The Manila media likes to hype this happening every year.

    The deluded people who have themselves ‘crucified’, thinking it is the will of God, aren’t really opposing any Church teaching as such. They are refusing to take the advice of their bishops.

    Recently 30 priests in Pampanga, in one barrio of which most of the ‘crucifixions’ take place, concelebrated Mass for the birthday of a congresswoman whose term as president coincided with the stench of unbounded corruption. One might ask who are really being cruciifed in Pampanga and elsewhere in the Philippines and who are the ones hammering in the nails.

    Yes, the tradition of corruption does indeed trump Church teaching.

submit to reddit
  • Print This Post
  • Email This Post
  • share this post
  • From the blessings of Palm Sunday to Easter Sunday’s dawn procession, Filipinos celebrate Holy Week with unparalleled commitment and fervor. The celebrations are at their most intense on Good Friday, when the passion of Our Lord is re-enacted with bloodcurdling realism

Pictures by Joe Torres
top stories

search

  • between
  • and
ucanews logo
ucanews advertisement policy